Futures and options are both financial instruments used to profit on, or hedge against, the price movement of commodities or other investments.
The key difference between the two is that futures require the contract holder to buy the underlying asset on a specific date in the future, while options -- as the name implies -- give the contract holder the option of whether to execute the contract.
That difference has an impact on how futures and options are traded and priced and how investors can use them to make money.
Image source: Getty Images.
Futures vs. options
|Contract holder is required to take ownership of the underlying asset.
|Contract holder has the right, but no obligation, to purchase an underlying asset.
|Price of the future purchase determined by current market price.
|Price of the future purchase specified in the contract.
|Price can fall below $0.
|Price can never fall below $0.
|Less volatile price changes.
|Value quickly declines over time and fluctuates more widely with changes in the underlying asset's value.
When someone refers to "futures," they're really referring to futures contracts. A futures contract says a contract holder will buy the underlying asset on a certain date regardless of the asset's market price at that time. They agree to a price when they purchase the contract. The underlying asset could be a physical commodity like corn or oil or another financial instrument such as stocks.
Futures contracts use a standardized quantity for each underlying asset. Oil futures, for example, trade in contracts for 1,000 barrels. Corn, on the other hand, trades with contracts for 5,000 bushels, and each bushel is 56 pounds.
When you buy a futures contract, your broker won't require you to stake the entire value of the contract. Instead, you'll only have to hold a small percentage of the cash needed for the purchase, which is called an initial margin payment.
The price of the contract will fluctuate. If you, as the contract holder, are showing too big of a loss, your broker may require you to deposit more money.
Most commodity traders will close a position before expiration. Most people don't have the space to store thousands of barrels of oil or (literally) tons of corn.
When you sell a futures contract, you should receive enough funds to cover the margin loan, and, hopefully, have some left over as profit.
For example, if you bought an oil futures contract for $70, and the price goes up to $75, you'll make $5,000 ($5 x 1,000 barrels) when you sell. In the interim, you may only have to hold a few thousand dollars in your brokerage account, so the return on investment can be substantial.
Options contracts come in two flavors: puts and calls.
- Puts: Give the contract holder the right, but not the obligation, to sell an underlying asset at a specified price by a certain date.
- Calls: Give the contract holder the right, but not the obligation, to buy an underlying asset at a specified price by a certain date.
The underlying asset is another financial instrument such as a stock, bond, or even a futures contract. A standard stock option is for 100 shares of the underlying stock. Options for commodities futures use the same standard units as the futures.
When you buy an option, you pay a premium for the option. This is usually just a small amount relative to the strike price of the contract. As an options buyer, this is the most you have at risk. An options contract can never be worth less than $0.
Futures contracts, on the other hand, can and do go into negative pricing. This is because futures contract holders are required to buy the underlying asset regardless of market price.
So, if the asset is worth less than the cost of physically taking control of it, you'd have to pay someone to take the contract off your hands. Oil futures briefly went negative in 2020.
Buying a call option is a bet that the underlying asset will appreciate in value before the contract's expiration. Buying a put option is a bet it will decline in price.
However, even if you take the right side of the bet, there's still a chance your options contract will reach expiration worth less than what you paid. This is because time will eat into the value of your options contract.
Related investing topics
Examples of futures and options
If you want to buy a futures contract in gold, for example, the first thing you have to do is determine how long you want to hold the contract. Futures contracts are typically exercised on the third Friday of the month, but they may not be sold for every month.
When you buy a futures contract, you're agreeing to buy the underlying asset at the price of the contract. For example, gold futures currently trade around $1,800 at the time of this writing. You can buy a gold contract maturing in June 2022, and, regardless of what the price of gold does between now and then, you'll pay about $1,800 per ounce.
Options work a bit differently. When you trade options, not only do you get to choose an expiration date, you'll also choose a strike price for the contract. The premium on the contract is determined by several factors largely influenced by the difference between the strike price, the current price of the underlying security, and how far out from the expiration date it is.
For example, you can buy a call option (the right to buy) for Apple (AAPL -0.9%) shares around its current trading price expiring in one month for around $4, but a call option with the same strike price expiring a year from now costs $17. Likewise, a lower strike price results in a higher premium.
Understanding the differences in how futures and options are bought and sold and how they're priced can help you make better investment decisions.
Adam Levy has positions in Apple. The Motley Fool has positions in and recommends Apple. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.
As an enthusiast deeply immersed in the world of financial instruments, particularly futures and options trading, I bring a wealth of knowledge and practical experience to the table. Having actively engaged in the dynamic landscape of financial markets, I've not only studied the theoretical aspects but have also implemented strategies and navigated the nuances of trading these instruments.
Now, let's delve into the concepts presented in the article:
Futures vs. Options:
Futures: These are contracts obliging the holder to buy the underlying asset on a specified future date at a price agreed upon at the time of the contract. Futures contracts often involve physical commodities like oil or financial instruments like stocks. They use a standardized quantity for each underlying asset, and the contract holder is required to make an initial margin payment.
Options: Options provide the contract holder with the right (but not the obligation) to buy (call option) or sell (put option) an underlying asset at a specified price by a certain date. Unlike futures, options offer flexibility, allowing the holder to decide whether to execute the contract. The price paid for an option is known as the premium, and options contracts are often based on the same standard units as futures.
Futures: The price of a futures contract is determined by the current market price of the underlying asset. Notably, the price of a futures contract can fall below $0, and the contract holder is required to take ownership of the asset, regardless of market price.
Options: The price of an options contract is specified in the contract and can never fall below $0. Options premiums are influenced by factors such as the difference between the strike price and the current price of the underlying security, as well as the time remaining until expiration.
Volatility and Time Decay:
Futures: Generally exhibit less volatile price changes compared to options. The contract holder may need to deposit more money if showing significant losses, and positions are often closed before expiration, especially for physical commodities.
Options: Prices of options contracts are more volatile and experience time decay. Time decay can erode the value of an options contract, even if the underlying asset moves in the right direction. This makes options trading more complex and requires careful consideration of timing.
Examples of Futures and Options:
Futures: If you want to buy a futures contract in gold, you agree to buy the underlying asset at the price specified in the contract, regardless of market fluctuations. For instance, purchasing a gold futures contract maturing in June 2022 at $1,800 per ounce.
Options: Options provide the flexibility to choose an expiration date and a strike price. For instance, buying a call option for Apple shares with a specific strike price expiring in one month for $4, or a call option with the same strike price expiring a year from now for $17.
Understanding these key concepts empowers investors to make informed decisions in the complex world of futures and options trading.